Archive for October, 2010

Women in IT and Open Source: a controversial topic

Thursday, October 21st, 2010

Some time has passed since the Open World Forum, Paris took place, where I participated in the Diversity Summit: Why women matter? think tank.

You can download my presentation on the “Importance of women values in IThere. I’ll also post an article about it on this blog soon.

Now, I just would like to highlight my feeling about this topic, as a result of my participation in the forum.

First of all, it was a great experience and I thank once more Marie Buhot-Launay, the organizer, who invited me. This was an opportunity to promote a collective effort, in which I’m doing my best to involve girls and women in the IT context.

But I know that I’m dealing with a controversial topic.

I met an open source testimonial (a man) telling me: “Be careful! I’ve decided time ago not to deal with this topic! Any word you adopt may be misunderstood”.

Actually, at the meeting some women held a very “feminist” position, judging all my words.

Ok, we all have different histories, attitudes, cultures and … I’m and old-aged and old-fashioned man … However, please let me do my best effort if it can help. Judge contents of my speeches and actions. I’m open to any debate. I think that just the will of doing something which may improve the situation is a good thing (and consider that I live in Europe and Italy, and the “gender diversity issue in IT” is probably mainly an European -and Italian – issue!)

But I’d like to give you an example now.

The day before the Diversity Summit I participated in the Open Source Think Tank Paris .

During a conversation I grabbed this sentence: “If you have to promote open source, you must tell stories to potential adopters and you must put emotion into your stories”.

As a consequence, I decided to open my talk with this anecdote, asking the following: “OSS market is dominated by men. Now my question is: are men really able to put emotion into their stories?

Well, after one day, a women asked me: “Do you really think that women are better suited to put emotion in stories than men? It’s a typical stereotype, because you think that women deal with maternity, love, etc. It’s just culture, no biological motivation exists”.

Something like: emotions deal with women and rationality with men! Ugly man, you promote the usual stereotypes!

I don’t know if it’s a stereotype or not. To be honest, stereotypes can be used in order to develop a schema of reasoning which can support people in facing a complex topic. Moreover, stereotypes may be a means to understand a specific issue and find out a result. To do this, they must not be the result itself. But it’s not my point.

I’m answering with an example now.

This year, Open World Forum was a great event. More internationalization, better organized (even though last year it was very well organized too), a lot of interesting talks and tracks: a very difficult choice. And some up-to-date talks (which is not usual in open source events).

As usual, many of the speakers were men.

Among others, I attended the speech by Noiry Shirley, vice-president of Apache Software Foundation. A great speech, probably one of the very few speeches (if not the only one) putting real emotion in the story. The format, the content, the speaker’s participation! Thank you Shirley! A great example of communication and of what open source is!

I don’t know if emotions deal with women, but if the previous is a result, we definitively need more women in the FOSS world (to teach many men how to work and communicate, at least)!

Education to foster the Open Source adoption

Thursday, October 21st, 2010

Time ago, I wrote something about the need for education in Computer Science and Free Open Source Software in this blog.

Now, I’m going to chair a panel about this topic at fOSSa 2010, at the end of an interesting education track open by a lightning talk by Roberto Di Cosmo.

In particular, the education track will deal with the role of academia in education, focusing on three main aspects: education of the teachers, education of all the university students, specific education of IT students teaching how to work in an environment that is more and more dominated by Free Open Source Software.

Many talks, by Gilles Dowek, Ralf Treinen, Jesus Barahona, Wouter Tebbens, Judith Benzakki, Albert Cohen and Alexandre Lefebvre will introduce a final debate.

My aim is to chair it, both as a traditional panel, asking some questions to any of the above-mentioned speakers, and partly as an unconference panel, involving as many people of the audience as possible. I think that asking questions in advance is a good means to prepare an interesting debate that will rise its end at the conference, and you can do it right now.

Personally, I want to introduce some questions of mine asking for your feedback. Do you like it? Would you like to add anything else? Are they really interesting? Help me in finding the right question for speakers and attendees. I’d like not to have an auto-referential panel, but a place to gather new ideas and proposals to be brought to people that have a role in education at different levels to foster the right way of FOSS promotion.

Here are some questions.

to IT students

Which are the FOSS skills you need more? Technological ones, legal ones, community development, collaborative project management, others?

to students and professors

Which is the most useful subject to be taught at universities? FOSS technologies per-se? How to contribute in FOSS development? FOSS founding values? All of them?

Do you think the previous skills are specific only of a FOSS training course or a master, or should they be inserted into the traditional training program of IT courses?

to enterprises

What are your expectations about FOSS skills in hiring a student coming out from university? Do you care about IT skills only, or do you think that knowledge of FOSS specific aspects (legal, community development, collaboration, etc.) is valuable? Is it just valuable or crucial?

to everybody

How much the knowledge of FOSS by a group of skilled people (students, professors, entrepreneurs) must be supported by knowledge of FOSS values in the broader society? What should we practically do in order to support this dissemination?

I’ll stop here. Please comment, add more, where you like: on fOSSa forum, fOSSa linkedin group, my linkedin profile and, why not, on this blog!